The movie adaptation of Stephen
Chbosky’s Perks of Being a Wallflower
alters the relationship between Sam and Charlie in certain ways that turned
their relationship into something else entirely. The alterations allow Charlie
to be on more of an equal grounds with Sam instead of Sam always seeming like
the older more mature one. This alteration transforms their relationship so by
the end it can be assumed that they are in a romantic relationship unlike in
the books.
One major equalizer was how Sam
would confide in Charlie about her troubles and fears in the film. In the
novel, Charlie would usually be the one telling others about what was going on
with him or just listening. Sam would not fully confide in Charlie because she
was more of a mentor to him. She only truly confided in him with the secret
about her adolescent molestation whereas in the film she also told him about
her fears about getting into college. She told him she got a bad SAT score,
which prompted another major alteration. Charlie tutored Sam for her SATs,
which never happened in the novel. This alteration allows for Charlie to be the
one helping Sam out and giving them more of a give and take relationship. This
change helps Charlie to become Sam’s peer rather than always the freshman she
mentors. Since in the book, Sam always seems to be trying to teach Charlie life
lessons like how to go on dates with girls or helping him out by giving him his
first real kiss. These things happen in the movie, but with the added effect of
Charlie helping her, their relationship does not seem so much like a teacher
and student.
In effect, Sam and Charlie end up
presumably having sex before she leaves for college because of this equality
and the negation of a alarming memory of Charlie’s molestation. Charlie has a
faint hint of remembrance than tucks it away in the movie so that they can
consummate their relationship instead of it just being platonic. The novel
ended their relationship with friendship because the relationship would have
obviously not been healthy for either of the character that had been through
the same childhood trama and both needed to grow away from each other. On the
other hand, th movie ended with a happy sense that Sam and Charlie are now in a
more romantic relationship that Charlie and the reader were hoping for through
the kiss before Sam leaves for college and the final kiss in the tunnel. The
kiss in the tunnel allows the viewer to assume they are still together and in a
long distance relationship.
These major changes drastically
altered the relationship between Sam and Charlie. The changes shifted the
relationship to a one-sided romantic love to a connected romantic love through
the alterations in the plot.
Oh, I couldn't figure out if they did have sex or didn't have sex in the film! I thought his flashback of Aunt Helen when Sam was getting ready to drive away meant they didn't. It was confusing. I agree completely with how the changes affected their relationship. They definitely seemed like a romantic item, and Charlies promotion to being someone she confided in made them equals in a way that changed the dynamic of their relationship.
ReplyDeleteI agree that Charlie's character is different in the film when it comes to Sam. He seems less obsessed and also less innocent. I don't see the same struggle of power between the two of them though. Even though he is meek/weak in the novel, he always holds himself back from giving into Sam because they are "friends."
ReplyDeletePlaying in real money slots you get the chance to earn money by spending well time
ReplyDeleteCharlie is more fully realized in the movie in the novel my memory of him is being extremely stunted.
ReplyDelete